The meters seem to be responding in synch with the music. They are steady at 0 (-20) on power on through the start of play back. Then when the music starts the left meter has a sweeet spot where if the volume is low enough (background music level), it appears to have accurate movement. It's a narrow sweet spot though. A little less volume and it stays put at 0. Normal listening levels (for me) have it bouncing off of the rev limiter, while the right channel seems to be responding accurately. It's bouncing so hard off of the right stop that I think that is the distortion/rattle that I was hearing last night.
I'm going to lower the sensitivity on the left meter as much as possible through the jumpers (which is the least sensitive setting?) and maximize sensitivity on the right meter and see if I can even them out a bit. I'm also considering running the amp on my bench with the meter outputs connected to my oscilloscope where I can see what the meters are getting fed. I'm assuming it's the meter, but who knows, maybe I have a output signal disparity between the two channels to the meter (both speakers have equal volume and soundstage/imaging is excellent).