I'm looking for SACD sources...help please!
- Thread starter premiumplus
- Start date
Never heard Kitaro...Most of what the 90's gave us (at least in regards to rock) I can do without. I'm very much into old school rock; I do love everything Steely Dan and Donald Fagan put out. I wish "The Nightfly" or Mark Knopfler's "Sailing to Philidelphia" were on SACD. Earl Klugh also put out some very nice easy listening jazz that was very nicely recorded, but I haven't found any SACD of his stuff yet.
What's the deal with Blu Ray audio, any thoughts on that medium?
I'm really eager to find out how well the Oppo will up-sample redbook cd's. It fascinates me how post production processing by a player can interpolate data and get better sound from it. Very cool, and I want to learn more.
-Dave-
What's the deal with Blu Ray audio, any thoughts on that medium?
I'm really eager to find out how well the Oppo will up-sample redbook cd's. It fascinates me how post production processing by a player can interpolate data and get better sound from it. Very cool, and I want to learn more.
-Dave-
- Joined
- May 29, 2013
- Messages
- 2,909
To be honest this Police SACD isn't the best example of what this medium is capable of.
The 5.1 mixdown of it doesn't add the "WOW" effect to the original music which was meant as normal 2 channel stereo.
And that is also the main problem with this medium; Most of the SACD's are reissues remixed in "so called" multi-channel sound
Just on few reissues this is done almost perfect, but most of the multi-channel reissues are sounding like poor "pseudo" surround in the claimed 5.1. format.
As Nando said earlier; This Gaucho album is an exception and is sounding very good in the 5.1 format and not surprisingly: Donald Fagen and Walter Becker are famous about the way they produced ALL their music.
The 5.1 mixdown of it doesn't add the "WOW" effect to the original music which was meant as normal 2 channel stereo.
And that is also the main problem with this medium; Most of the SACD's are reissues remixed in "so called" multi-channel sound
Just on few reissues this is done almost perfect, but most of the multi-channel reissues are sounding like poor "pseudo" surround in the claimed 5.1. format.
As Nando said earlier; This Gaucho album is an exception and is sounding very good in the 5.1 format and not surprisingly: Donald Fagen and Walter Becker are famous about the way they produced ALL their music.
- Joined
- Jan 14, 2011
- Messages
- 74,244
- Location
- Gillette, Wyo.
- Tagline
- Halfbiass...Electron Herder and Backass Woof
SACD is NOT a surround format Lee. It is a high resolution, high sample rate improvement to the old CD format. SACD is just the bit format, not how they mix it to the CD.
SACDs are available in straight 2 channel stereo format (I have some Diana Krall and Cindy Lauper SACDs recorded this way)
2 Channel stereo SACD with a second laser layer on the CD with conventional CD format (they call these hybrid SACDs, my entire Bob Dylan and Rolling Stones collection is recorded this way)
2 Channel stereo SACD with and alternate selectable 5.1 surround format (my Alison Krauss Live in Concert and Heart SACD are recorded this way) (I only listen to the 2 channel selections on these)
I am sure there are other variants, the above are the most common. They use DVD type media so there are multiple layers they can access to store away different channel options.
SACDs are available in straight 2 channel stereo format (I have some Diana Krall and Cindy Lauper SACDs recorded this way)
2 Channel stereo SACD with a second laser layer on the CD with conventional CD format (they call these hybrid SACDs, my entire Bob Dylan and Rolling Stones collection is recorded this way)
2 Channel stereo SACD with and alternate selectable 5.1 surround format (my Alison Krauss Live in Concert and Heart SACD are recorded this way) (I only listen to the 2 channel selections on these)
I am sure there are other variants, the above are the most common. They use DVD type media so there are multiple layers they can access to store away different channel options.
- Joined
- May 29, 2013
- Messages
- 2,909
Well Gepetto, this is a perfect explanation of what SACD really is, I couldn't have done it better!
But: (there's allways a but... and I'm gonna quite now):
This is one of the reasons SACD didn't make it to the mass and is starving a slow and silent death.
In my opinion it's nonsense to release albums (which were recorded mostly using recording and mastering technologies of 40+ years ago) on an high end medium like SACD.
Does it really sound better than it did before? Or is it just the placebo effect we want to believe in?
But: (there's allways a but... and I'm gonna quite now):
This is one of the reasons SACD didn't make it to the mass and is starving a slow and silent death.
In my opinion it's nonsense to release albums (which were recorded mostly using recording and mastering technologies of 40+ years ago) on an high end medium like SACD.
Does it really sound better than it did before? Or is it just the placebo effect we want to believe in?
I can play the redbook track or SACD track on hybrid SACDs, same player, same system. The SACD track sounds like vinyl does (without the background surface noise) and the CD track does not. That is the most noticeable difference. That has all to do with the sampling rate.
Take a modern SACD recording, Norah Jones. All the latest equipment and mastering technology. Does not sound as good as some of the 40 year old tape mastered recordings.
Do you have any MOFI CDs? Do you notice a difference between the MOFI and standard CD?
Take a modern SACD recording, Norah Jones. All the latest equipment and mastering technology. Does not sound as good as some of the 40 year old tape mastered recordings.
Do you have any MOFI CDs? Do you notice a difference between the MOFI and standard CD?
Wikipedia answered a lot of questions for me.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sacd
From what I been reading, other than maybe grabbing 1 or 2 of these disc's simply to try them out, I dont think I'll invest much into them. While I do like CD's, Vinyl is still king for me.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sacd
From what I been reading, other than maybe grabbing 1 or 2 of these disc's simply to try them out, I dont think I'll invest much into them. While I do like CD's, Vinyl is still king for me.
- Joined
- May 29, 2013
- Messages
- 2,909
Fair enough, and at some point I totally agree with you.
However, I'm still curious about how some modern and older albums would sound on SACD.
For the modern: "Touch" by Yello (2009), and for the Old: "Tales Of Mystery And Imagination" by The Alan Parsons Project (1976) Both albums are reference productions of it's own generation and they will probably never be released on a SACD.
I have no experiences with MOFI CD's... Most of the titles available aren't my cup of tea, but that's just a matter of taste and personal and has nothing to do with the technology of it.
However, I'm still curious about how some modern and older albums would sound on SACD.
For the modern: "Touch" by Yello (2009), and for the Old: "Tales Of Mystery And Imagination" by The Alan Parsons Project (1976) Both albums are reference productions of it's own generation and they will probably never be released on a SACD.
I have no experiences with MOFI CD's... Most of the titles available aren't my cup of tea, but that's just a matter of taste and personal and has nothing to do with the technology of it.
I just received my copy of Gaucho on SACD yesterday. It sounds very nice in my Pioneer DV-45A.
I'm STILL WAITING for my Oppo BDP-105 to get here. It's been delayed 3 times because of weather...I ordered it 10 days ago.
Yesterday was the most painful...I tracked it as being "Out For Delivery" and settled in waiting for a sure thing knock at my door delivery. At about 4:30 I tracked it and got a "Delivery Exception-Local weather exception-delivery not attempted". Called FedEx and tried to get them to release it to me at the FedEx hub in Saginaw, about 30 miles north of me. They said that if it was a delivery to a business they would release it but since it was "Home Delivery" they would not. The lady that I do a lot of business with at the local FedEx store suggested I do a "Delivery Option" and get it delivered to their store. I did that, and they said they'd call me today when it is delivered.
I'm a pretty patient man but after 3 delays I'm getting antsy to get my new beautiful TOTL Oppo in my system, so I can enjoy it instead of reading reviews and instruction manuals. Geez...
I'm STILL WAITING for my Oppo BDP-105 to get here. It's been delayed 3 times because of weather...I ordered it 10 days ago.
Yesterday was the most painful...I tracked it as being "Out For Delivery" and settled in waiting for a sure thing knock at my door delivery. At about 4:30 I tracked it and got a "Delivery Exception-Local weather exception-delivery not attempted". Called FedEx and tried to get them to release it to me at the FedEx hub in Saginaw, about 30 miles north of me. They said that if it was a delivery to a business they would release it but since it was "Home Delivery" they would not. The lady that I do a lot of business with at the local FedEx store suggested I do a "Delivery Option" and get it delivered to their store. I did that, and they said they'd call me today when it is delivered.
I'm a pretty patient man but after 3 delays I'm getting antsy to get my new beautiful TOTL Oppo in my system, so I can enjoy it instead of reading reviews and instruction manuals. Geez...
To add another good source for SACDs, try Acoustic Sounds, acousticsounds.com, IIRC. That's Chad Kassem's equivalent to Music Direct and my other go-to site for music. Chad also owns Analogue Productions, which does, for my money, the best remasterings and pressings I've experienced. Most of the stuff they release on vinyl also comes out on SACD.
Their CCR set from some years ago remains to this day the finest vinyl I've ever purchased and his SACDs are just as good.
Their CCR set from some years ago remains to this day the finest vinyl I've ever purchased and his SACDs are just as good.
- Joined
- May 26, 2013
- Messages
- 713
- Location
- St. Louis, MO.
- Tagline
- Born and Raised In The 700 Watt Club.
Looking myself for a multi-disc SACD player. Anybody have a good one they know of? Besides a SONY 100-disc mega player? I am thinking about getting my father introduced to the hi-fidelity format, and he is used to current 6-disc magazine changers. So no stand-alone transport players.
Also, In anyone's opinion; what do you think is the best sounding example of the format? i.e. such as the aforementioned Dire Straits-Brothers In Arms? Or other Rock albums? etc................
Also, In anyone's opinion; what do you think is the best sounding example of the format? i.e. such as the aforementioned Dire Straits-Brothers In Arms? Or other Rock albums? etc................