THE Crossover Thread

George S.

Veteran and General Yakker
Joined
Feb 18, 2020
Messages
4,998
Did amp gain matching to the drivers today within the MiniDsp plugin to approximate a "Harman house curve" I downloaded into REW. Going to give this particular house curve a shot.
Boosted the 700 WOPL output by 10 dB for the subs.
Left the 400 WOPL output unchanged for the woofers.
Reduced the 400 WOPL output by 7 dB for the midrange.
Reduced the PL300S2 output by 5 dB for the tweeters.
Been testing different gain profiles all day. I'm surprised by how much small a gain structure change affects the sound.
Next up is generating the EQ filters and plugging them in to closely match the house curve, then time alignment of the drivers.
 

Attachments

laatsch55

Administrator,
Staff member
Joined
Jan 14, 2011
Messages
74,717
Location
Gillette, Wyo.
Tagline
Halfbiass...Electron Herder and Backass Woof
Yeah , I've noticed that too. Doesn't take much gain difference to make it sound not right...
The thing I didn't like about trip amping 10 years ago doesn't seem to bother me this time and that was getting things to sound right at a certain level and then cranking it and having to mess with.levels again.
 

George S.

Veteran and General Yakker
Joined
Feb 18, 2020
Messages
4,998
I'm running 10 Hz to 20 KHz sweeps set to a 76 dB level at the microphone for the calibration. The signal is random white noise from the REW signal generator. I'm not noticing any need to change the amp gain settings again.
I did some further tuning last night and was able to drop the subs amp gain from +10 to +8, and stay within the room curve. They'll stay there unless I go to a different curve.
I'm using the so called "Harman" loudspeaker curve commonly used on REW, and Psychoacoustic smoothing of the sweep results.
Both approximate how we hear sound.
 

grapplesaw

Veteran and General Yakker
Joined
Aug 13, 2014
Messages
2,775
Location
Vancouver
Tagline
---
Yeah , I've noticed that too. Doesn't take much gain difference to make it sound not right...
The thing I didn't like about trip amping 10 years ago doesn't seem to bother me this time and that was getting things to sound right at a certain level and then cranking it and having to mess with.levels again.
Well Lee with the PA2 you can control multiple memory points for different types and loudness Now the trick is to remember which is which
 

laatsch55

Administrator,
Staff member
Joined
Jan 14, 2011
Messages
74,717
Location
Gillette, Wyo.
Tagline
Halfbiass...Electron Herder and Backass Woof
I'm running 10 Hz to 20 KHz sweeps set to a 76 dB level at the microphone for the calibration. The signal is random white noise from the REW signal generator. I'm not noticing any need to change the amp gain settings again.
I did some further tuning last night and was able to drop the subs amp gain from +10 to +8, and stay within the room curve. They'll stay there unless I go to a different curve.
I'm using the so called "Harman" loudspeaker curve commonly used on REW, and Psychoacoustic smoothing of the sweep results.
Both approximate how we hear sound.
Are your ear and the eq adjustments always in agreement?
 

George S.

Veteran and General Yakker
Joined
Feb 18, 2020
Messages
4,998
They're in agreement from appx 30 Hz to 10 KHz. After that I can't hear unless the volume is turned way up around 100 dB. I don't do that anymore.
I consider REW and the Umik-1 mike, highly accurate, as it has widespread use in the industry by the professionals. Same with the MiniDsp.
Moved crossover points today from 800 Hz to 1000 Hz, and 3500 Hz to 4000 Hz. These are the points JBL used on these boxes originally.
Also summed the subs for the first time. I'm thinking that is the correct move, but I need to do a sweep against the house curve and look at gain with them summed.
My prior tinkering with REW has helped, but it's complicated. There's no good all comprehensive guide on how to do this
Spent time today reading about time alignment and impulse testing and how to set individual driver delays. I'm going to try to start on that tomorrow.
Tried learning this stuff years ago, but work interfered. Now I have the time to do it.
Listening to the first Infected Mushroom Converting Vegetarians. Hope I don't piss off my neighbors. The bass never stops. Finally getting the 700 WOPL broke in.
 

laatsch55

Administrator,
Staff member
Joined
Jan 14, 2011
Messages
74,717
Location
Gillette, Wyo.
Tagline
Halfbiass...Electron Herder and Backass Woof
They're in agreement from appx 30 Hz to 10 KHz. After that I can't hear unless the volume is turned way up around 100 dB. I don't do that anymore.
I consider REW and the Umik-1 mike, highly accurate, as it has widespread use in the industry by the professionals. Same with the MiniDsp.
Moved crossover points today from 800 Hz to 1000 Hz, and 3500 Hz to 4000 Hz. These are the points JBL used on these boxes originally.
Also summed the subs for the first time. I'm thinking that is the correct move, but I need to do a sweep against the house curve and look at gain with them summed.
My prior tinkering with REW has helped, but it's complicated. There's no good all comprehensive guide on how to do this
Spent time today reading about time alignment and impulse testing and how to set individual driver delays. I'm going to try to start on that tomorrow.
Tried learning this stuff years ago, but work interfered. Now I have the time to do it.
Listening to the first Infected Mushroom Converting Vegetarians. Hope I don't piss off my neighbors. The bass never stops. Finally getting the 700 WOPL broke in.
Converting Vegetarians at 110 db plus has some fine sonic impact. The floor Tom especially can make me jump at times.
A feature of the Ashly is being able to mute any driver of any channel. After muting the woof and the tweeter it was pretty evident why the mid horns deserved the big bucks..
 

George S.

Veteran and General Yakker
Joined
Feb 18, 2020
Messages
4,998
The ability to mute individual drivers is important for setting the impulse timing.
I plan on making one of the subs the timing standard, then align all the other drivers to it one by one.
The ability to mute the individual drivers is in the MiniDsp plugin software. The impulse measuring functions are in REW.
One of the shortcomings of the now "Legacy" MiniDsp I use is it only offers 9 ms of delay per driver. The new units offer much more.
Hopefully 9 ms will be enough for the drivers in the JBL cabinets. The sub cabinets can be physically moved forward or backward to fall within spec. From what I've read the 9 ms span is mostly a issue with home theater subs spread around a room.
We'll see.
 

laatsch55

Administrator,
Staff member
Joined
Jan 14, 2011
Messages
74,717
Location
Gillette, Wyo.
Tagline
Halfbiass...Electron Herder and Backass Woof
The ability to mute individual drivers is important for setting the impulse timing.
I plan on making one of the subs the timing standard, then align all the other drivers to it one by one.
The ability to mute the individual drivers is in the MiniDsp plugin software. The impulse measuring functions are in REW.
One of the shortcomings of the now "Legacy" MiniDsp I use is it only offers 9 ms of delay per driver. The new units offer much more.
Hopefully 9 ms will be enough for the drivers in the JBL cabinets. The sub cabinets can be physically moved forward or backward to fall within spec. From what I've read the 9 ms span is mostly a issue with home theater subs spread around a room.
We'll see.

The PS2 Driverack has those features also.
They have pre-loaded crossover specs for alot of speakers. Plenty of preloaded crossover setups.....but none for a speaker that has been in continuous production since 1947....AND.. .the is no preloaded straight 3 way crossover profile....with woof, mid and tweet. A lot of sub and two wsy...

I was stunned....
 

George S.

Veteran and General Yakker
Joined
Feb 18, 2020
Messages
4,998
I made a polarity error at the very start. The JBL's have the well documented negative polarity where the cones pull in during battery testing. I checked each driver individually for DCR and polarity, and was very careful in rewiring the cabinets. The subs are standard positive polarity, duh!
Reversed polarity on the subs to match the JBL's and was able to drop all extra gain matching from the sub amp to match the Harman curve. Details, details, details!
 

Gepetto

Administrator
Staff member
Joined
May 15, 2011
Messages
13,877
Location
Sterling, MA
Tagline
Old 'Arn Enthusiast
I made a polarity error at the very start. The JBL's have the well documented negative polarity where the cones pull in during battery testing. I checked each driver individually for DCR and polarity, and was very careful in rewiring the cabinets. The subs are standard positive polarity, duh!
Reversed polarity on the subs to match the JBL's and was able to drop all extra gain matching from the sub amp to match the Harman curve. Details, details, details!
plus it sounds better that way...
 

J!m

Veteran and General Yakker
Joined
Dec 24, 2019
Messages
10,601
Location
Connecticut
Tagline
BOT
Um, 9ms is like 3 meters. That should be plenty and I would be concerned about having fine enough resolution between 0 and 9ms.
 

George S.

Veteran and General Yakker
Joined
Feb 18, 2020
Messages
4,998
Been reading about and watching home theater setup videos for several days.
Even the professionals have differences in how they implement active DSP crossovers.
Nice thing about software is it's easy to discard preferences and reboot to a fresh slate. Been doing a lot of that.
Getting there through trial and error. Slowly.
 

George S.

Veteran and General Yakker
Joined
Feb 18, 2020
Messages
4,998
Impulse measurement of the JBL tweeter and midrange. The midrange has a 1 ms delay applied to it. The tweeter has no delay, therefore the tweeter fires before the midrange. The horizontal graph is time in ms, with the tweeter indexed at t=0. Mid driver with 1 ms delay..jpg

Precise measurements can be made. Here is the peak of the midrange at 1.152 ms.
Close up.jpg

To align the two. Take the 1 ms delay off the midrange, and apply a 0.152 ms delay to the tweeter. And, we have this, driver alignment. The midrange is aligned to the tweeter.
Tweeter and mid aligned..jpg

The woofer is similarly aligned to the midrange with delay placed on the midrange. That delay is then added to the tweeter delay. So midrange and tweeter are then aligned to the woofer.
The woofers will have no delay until individual cabinets are aligned to each other. Then one woofer will have a delay, and that delay will be added to the other drivers within the cabinet.
It gets complicated quickly, and the REW software is stellar, but also complicated.
 
Last edited:

George S.

Veteran and General Yakker
Joined
Feb 18, 2020
Messages
4,998
Not for drivers within the cabinet. Only if you move the cabinets in relation to other cabinets you've matched timing to. Guess that's why they mark the floor.
This rabbit hole goes very deep. They talk about much that I don't understand and use shorthand phrases for words I need to look up, and still don't get. This driver timing is extremely basic and important in setting up a system.
The ability to precision measure impulses with REW and a Umik mike is rather amazing.
Lots of functions in the software, and it appears to be very popular with the Pros.
 

mr_rye89

Veteran and General Yakker
Joined
Aug 12, 2015
Messages
2,592
Location
Land of Entrapment
Tagline
Lost in the Ozone Again
This is interesting, I put a little delay on my woofers cuz they sit ahead of my tweeters a bit. The voice coils of the tweeters are on the back of the compression drivers.... The Dayton app has the delay in in/cm but I read those don't work, only on milliseconds. I got the delay set under 1 ms I think, I'm not sure of the distance between the voice coils of the drivers......
 
Top