You could easily see the wear pattern in my case. But at your case, it looks like something electronic and not mechanical (in my book, the wear of the heads is mechanical and not electronic issue). Since you switched the whole frond with another and the issue continues to exist, then it's not mechanical. It's something on the pcb. Alex was clearly identified the problem as overbiasing. In my opinion, you have to find out why. A deck should not behave like that.
Sorry I can't give you some serious help.