I had an Orville Black Beauty several years ago, they are great guitars indeed. Most of my Les Paul's and Explorer's were Kalamazoo made but I also have had a few Nashville made Gibson's (including my current Explorer) which are just as good in every respect. I am a little wary of the new lines Gibson has come out with though... Traditional, Traditional Plus ect...
Yeah...I bypassed all that stuff. Had a dear friend who is no longer with us (RIP Gary) that used to find the cream of the crop of the new stuff but even he bought that Orville from me then cried after he sold it back to me.
I've saw so many horrors from the new "Custom Shops" that it was insane and from both Fender and Gibson. I'm talking about things like truss rod rattling around in their pocket......For a long time I know the Fender CS was just putting a few US things on Mexican made guitars and them "Hand Selecting" them when you called in an order.
Anyway, a quality guitar is as subjective as using Kimber Kables so I don't argue to much these days with folks.
Heck, my buddy Mike ran a shop rebuilding the old catalog guitars (Silvertone, Kay, Harmony....) into guitars that were every bit if not better than the Gibsons and Fenders of the time. It took effort but he made them into amazing "sticks" as he called them......