Update on this...I replaced both ICs and the Opamp on both boards and we are back in business on both LED boards...all caps and diodes were replaced previously as well.
Also, I bought a stash of both the blue and red 10-segment new style LED bars and Dremel cut down one of the 10 segment red and blue to 6 segments so everything fits nice. The blue is very cool, but to avoid looking orange, the red filter would need to be changed to blue. The new red LED bars are a huge improvement over the original and I may just leave it red. I'll post pictures of the blue on the board and the red from behind the filter to give you the idea of the brightness.
thanks for all the help guys!