That felt ring was a "peel & stick" and it came off without any difficulty at all.
For some reason, I woke up at 4:30 this morning and my first thought was Princess Automotive. It's a Canadian chain store that sells all manner of cheap Made In China hardware and it seems they carry a 12 piece hollow punch set for $19.99. They're open Sundays so I'll wander in later and take a look.
1/8, 5/32, 3/16, 7/32, 1/4, 5/16, 3/8, 7/16, 1/2, 9/16, 5/8, 3/4 in.
This will obviously not be of the highest quality but should be sufficient to make a felt ring or two. The sizes I need look like 5/8" OD - 3/8" ID and this set includes both.
Lee, you have good ideas!
But I'm back to thinking about the felt itself.
Skywavebe, you recommended 1.5 mm and I measured what I bought with calipers and it does indeed appear to be that thickness. Since the old ring came off intact, I measured it too and in it's present state it is 1 mm. As I won't know if it works or not until I put the deck back together, in your opinion, is this new felt likely to be OK? I'm concerned because I doubt that brass keeper could take many re & re's.