Well. I got caught up in this right from the beginning. I ended up taking this to a cool place in VT
http://www.victrolarepairservice.com/
I had the reproducer rebuilt, with new mica and gaskets. They also pulled the springs and replaced the 100 yr old grease from the housings and gears.
[attachment=2:3jv90whj]IMG_0421.JPG[/attachment:3jv90whj]
It now keeps true speed at 78 rpm, set right at the indicator and no longer "clunks"
I also picked up a product called "Kotton Klenser". It reminds me of Go-Jo, which is great for cleaning black grease off your hands. This thing really needed a deep cleaning, without stripping off all the old finish. It's in progress, and the lighting is different, but now you can actually see that this is oak!
Before:
[attachment=1:3jv90whj]Before.JPG[/attachment:3jv90whj]
After:
[attachment=0:3jv90whj]After.JPG[/attachment:3jv90whj]
I left the inside cover completely alone as not to mess with the old victrola decal and also because it was in really nice shape. It served as a good reference for color.
This a little more clean up, but the original finish is maintained without stripping, back to factory sound and operation. I did toss a replacement knob for the motor board too.