Hey Dave, I'm not familiar with your project gear, how sensitive is it? Does walking near it cause issues? What type of flooring/sub flooring is it on?
Are you hearing smears in the sf in the highs or the lows? Air borne issues...i.e. bass for the speakers?
I would go the cheap fun route. I'm sure Chicago has a used sporting goods store, get 4 used hockey pucks, hit the local Home Depot for 4 small pieces of MDF board and if they have any hardwood, get 4 small pieces of that, play with the wood on top, bottom and sandwiching the hockey pucks!
You can always get some spiked cones on line to transfer energy up or down...you can even use 3 pieces (Steve Evans uses 3 on his amps) instead of 4, drive yourself nuts buddy!!
In my tiny NYC apt I had no place to put my Thorens except on top of the sub woofer and it's wonderful sub chassis suspension allowed no nasties
to come through. The above mentioned Steve Evans confirmed that the TD 125 MKII has one of the finest isolated suspended platters out there for a reasonable amount of money, I say this because I'm not sure what a slab of granite costs for your needs