The 4558s do seem to have failed on both amps. When I pulled them, the 15v rails stabilized (previously all over the place and causing the 3k 5w resistors to run scalding hot) and Hi-Freq lights went off.
I went ahead and took an inventory of all caps and opamps, and ordered new+extras from Mouser. I also ordered some new resistors to replace some select ones that look to have run hot for a while. When the order comes in I'm going to recap everything and replace the opamps. I am going to go the socket route and ordered 4558s for testing as well as OPA2134 to use in the final product once I'm confident they won't be quickly destroyed.
I'm looking at PS cap replacement but haven't made a decision yet. Each amp currently uses 2x 125v 13000uf caps and I'm looking at 160v, 20000uf+ replacements, but they're expensive.
All the LEDs work great!
I'm still trying to figure out why one amp is permanently on. The power switch itself hasn't failed, but I can't find the issue. Hoping I'll run across it when recapping anything. Any thoughts? The impedance switch on the other amp doesn't work, but I haven't even taken a look at it.
None of the fuses for the output transistors blow, so that seems like a good sign.