My new, old DAC
- Thread starter J!m
- Start date
I did a rolling comparison between IC7 op-amps when I worked on the C1. Used an AudioControl SA-4140i SPL calibrated mic with integrated pink noise generator feeding the C1's AUX input. No EQ or other processing nor hologram processing. Nothing was changed in the room (placement, furniture, volume/SPL, etc.) except the op-amp in each of the tests.
My final verdict was to leave the (modern day production TI) 4136 in that position. I also replaced the other 8 4136 op-amps inside the chassis...just because. Also refreshed all the electrolytics, as well as installed non-polar electrolytics in the signal path (thank you Phoenix!).
The OPA2134 was most harsh to me - did not like that one at all.
And I realize this is not a scientific experiment, but thought it might be of interest.
Al
My final verdict was to leave the (modern day production TI) 4136 in that position. I also replaced the other 8 4136 op-amps inside the chassis...just because. Also refreshed all the electrolytics, as well as installed non-polar electrolytics in the signal path (thank you Phoenix!).
The OPA2134 was most harsh to me - did not like that one at all.
And I realize this is not a scientific experiment, but thought it might be of interest.
Al
Attachments
Last edited:
Well, I have the following on hand, ready to test:
LT1358
LM6172
LM4562
Originals on the board are NE5532 (and possibly "fake", due to origin of the board)
I was advised that the LM6172 is not suitable, so that's off the table now. I may try it anyway, since I already have them on hand.
@Gepetto : care to chime in on the output op amps for the DAC?
LT1358
LM6172
LM4562
Originals on the board are NE5532 (and possibly "fake", due to origin of the board)
I was advised that the LM6172 is not suitable, so that's off the table now. I may try it anyway, since I already have them on hand.
@Gepetto : care to chime in on the output op amps for the DAC?
Looking forward to your analysis. Do you know if the same board or an updated version is available from ebay? I'm sure there are others who have since put up their offerings by now. I've had mixed success with pre-built boards from over there ... quality of capacitors is always suspicious, in my opinion, but I guess you get what you pay for.
No, this particular one is not. Plenty of newer ESS boards these days. Even a dual mono version with the eight converted paralleled for each channel.
The idea is very good but no one shares schematicsnof their implementation, so I can’t have it evaluated (since I can’t do that part) before I build.
This one was built by a bunch of members at DIY audio and I got one back then. I also got a pair of Lundhal output transformers, as that was supposed to be the hot set up, but I’ve since learned better- trannies add distortion and I’m not a fan. But that would give a more “tube like” sound I presume, if your into that sort of thing.
So, I do want to do a parallel ESS assembly, because done right, this is really special, but I need to know the circuit was done correctly before I dive in.
The idea is very good but no one shares schematicsnof their implementation, so I can’t have it evaluated (since I can’t do that part) before I build.
This one was built by a bunch of members at DIY audio and I got one back then. I also got a pair of Lundhal output transformers, as that was supposed to be the hot set up, but I’ve since learned better- trannies add distortion and I’m not a fan. But that would give a more “tube like” sound I presume, if your into that sort of thing.
So, I do want to do a parallel ESS assembly, because done right, this is really special, but I need to know the circuit was done correctly before I dive in.
